Choosing a website platform feels like a design decision. But if no one can find you on Google, what’s the point?
So here’s the straight-up answer:
If you care about SEO, WordPress is your best bet.
It gives you full control, powerful plugins and advanced features that help you actually show up in search results. Squarespace covers the basics, sure, but it’s not built to help you scale your organic traffic long-term.
This guide breaks down the real differences between Squarespace and WordPress, purely through the SEO lens. You’ll learn which one gives you the best shot at ranking higher, faster and with less frustration.
TL:DR
- Squarespace: Great for beginners who want a no-fuss setup
- WordPress: Better for traffic growth, technical SEO and long-term scalability
- If Google is part of your marketing plan, go with WordPress
Squarespace vs WordPress: Quick Overview
Squarespace is the minimalist’s dream. Everything’s bundled in – hosting, templates, analytics, even email if you want it. It’s polished, clean and quick to set up.
WordPress.org is open-source and ridiculously powerful. With the right plugins and setup, it becomes an SEO beast. You just need to know how to tame it.
New to WordPress? Here’s your cheat sheet: Is WordPress Good for Small Business?
Squarespace SEO: What You Get (and What You Don’t)
What Squarespace Does Well
- Editable meta titles and descriptions
- Clean, readable URLs
- Mobile-friendly templates
- SSL certificates built-in
- Auto-generated sitemaps
It’s everything you need to launch and start ranking for your business name and some long-tail keywords. No dev needed. No plugin stress.
Where Squarespace Falls Short
- No SEO plugins or advanced tooling
- No built-in schema markup
- No control over image optimisation or caching
- No access to server settings
- Limited options for redirects
If you’re trying to rank for competitive keywords, build a content hub or implement advanced SEO strategies, you’ll hit a wall – fast.
And while it’s great that Squarespace does the heavy lifting, that same simplicity means you can’t customise the stuff that really matters for SEO performance.
WordPress SEO: The Control Freak’s Dream
Why WordPress Wins
- Install advanced SEO plugins like Yoast, Rank Math or AIOSEO
- Add structured data using Schema plugins
- Create custom URLs and canonical tags
- Optimise site speed with caching tools
- Manage redirects with ease
- Control every line of code, if you want to
With WordPress, you’re not locked into a template. You can build a site that loads faster, ranks better and adapts to SEO trends as they evolve.
Plus, the ecosystem is massive. That means constant innovation and more SEO support resources than you’ll ever need. Start here: SEO for Beginners
What to Watch Out For
- Setup takes longer
- Requires more maintenance
- You’ll need to manage plugins, backups and updates
- Learning curve is steeper if you’re doing it all yourself
The trade-off? You get flexibility, scalability and SEO performance that’s built to last.
Need help building it right the first time? Let’s talk: Web Design + SEO
Real-World Example
One of our clients was stuck on Squarespace. Nice-looking site, solid branding, zero organic traffic.
We migrated them to WordPress, installed Rank Math, cleaned up their structure and introduced schema markup and better content targeting.
The result?
- 260% increase in organic traffic
- Landing pages ranking in top 3 spots
- Conversions up
- Client no longer panicking over Google Analytics
SEO is a long game, but the right platform gives you a head start.
Time and Cost Breakdown
Squarespace
- Plans: $18 to $54/month
- Domain: ~$25/year
- Setup: A few hours
- Maintenance: Basically none
- Plugins: Not available
WordPress
- Hosting: $5 to $30/month
- Domain: ~$25/year
- Themes/Plugins: Free to $150+
- Setup: A day or two if DIY
- Maintenance: Updates, backups, plugin management
WordPress looks more complex, and it is. But in the long run, it often ends up being cheaper and far more powerful for SEO.
Curious about the full breakdown? How much does a website really cost?
Or what to budget before building
SEO Feature Showdown
| Feature | Squarespace | WordPress |
|---|---|---|
| Meta tags | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes + full control |
| Clean URLs | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Schema markup | ❌ No | ✅ Easily added |
| SEO plugins | ❌ None | ✅ Thousands available |
| Redirect management | ❌ Basic only | ✅ Plugin-controlled |
| Image optimisation | ❌ Limited | ✅ Full control |
| Page speed optimisation | ❌ Not customisable | ✅ Fully customisable |
| Technical SEO tweaks | ❌ Not accessible | ✅ Full access |
So… Which Should You Choose?
If your SEO goals are limited to “have a presence online,” Squarespace might be enough. It’s easy, safe and looks great.
But if you want to:
- Compete in search
- Rank your blog posts
- Get traffic without paid ads
- Scale content and optimise technical SEO
Then WordPress is your platform. It gives you the tools, control and features to win the long game.
Next Steps
Still deciding? Dive deeper here:
- Shopify vs WordPress: Which is better for SEO and ecommerce?
- Which website builder is right for you?
- Custom websites vs templates
- What goes into building a website
Or if you’re ready to hand it off and finally build a site that works, we’d love to help: Contact us